The further I look into the recent recalls of toys from China the more disturbed I am. I was railing about food and drugs that have been recalled when I added an update at the end of
this piece about the “Thomas the train” recall. After a week, much more has been revealed about toy recalls from China. Every single toy that has been recalled this year has come from China, EVERY SINGLE ONE!! In one case last month a fake floating eyeball toy
made in China was found to be filled with KEROSENE!! The all American toy (again made in China) the “easy-bake oven” was also recalled this year for “
entrapment and burn” hazards. Lets not forget the Thomas the train recall; 1.5. million toys were recalled last week by the RC2 Corporation,
here is a PDF file that lists all the recalls and shows pictures of all the toys, its 3 pages long!
This isn’t the first recall for this corporation, in fact the company website lists several more:
-including the all-American brand
John Deere.
-A 2006 recall of baby
teething rings.
-A 2003 recall of Lamaze toys again because of lead paint
While it would seem that I could beat up on this corporation for yet ANOTHER lead paint recall I will point out that 60% of ALL product recalls in the U.S. are from Chinese manufacturing. This is hardly an isolated incident! 70 to 80% of the toys sold in this country originate in China according to the Toy Industry Association. A recent article by the NY Times reports:
Over all, the number of products made in China that are being recalled in the
United States by the federal Consumer
Product Safety Commission has doubled in the last five years, driving the
total number of recalls in the country to 467 last year, an annual record.
In another article in the NY Times on the same subject a corporate apologist does his best impersonation of dubyah:
“I think the company does a great job,” said Sean McGowan, managing director and
toy industry analyst at Wedbush Morgan Securities, a brokerage firm in Los
Angeles. “Yes, this should have been caught earlier. But it wasn’t caught by
some kid getting sick. They caught it.”
Mr. McGowan said he had spoken with
Curt Stoelting, RC2’s chief executive, after the news came out, and that Mr.
Stoelting told him the problem was found during a routine quality check.
Allow me a moment to respond to this moron.
This “company that does a great job” has just recalled a million and a half toys in one shot not to mention the other recalls I listed. According to the CPSC lead paint can
cause irreversible brain damage in children and can retard mental and physical growth.
“this should have been caught earlier”, the recall spans 2 years(2005-2007)!
“the problem was found during a routine quality check” then why does the recall span 2 years? Was it a Bi-Annual quality?
That feels better, thanks for your patience!
Something that should be of concern in the future is the dismantling of the government watchdog groups that the Bush administration has been doing. In the
first NY Times article I mentioned (password required) the dismantling is detailed:
The toy industry in the United States is largely self-policed. The Consumer
Product Safety Commission has safety standards, but it has only about 100 field
investigators and compliance personnel nationwide to conduct inspections at
ports, warehouses and stores of $22 billion worth of toys and tens of billions
of dollars’ worth of other consumer products sold in the country each year.
“They don’t have the staff that they need to try to get ahead of this problem,”
said Janell Mayo Duncan, senior counsel at the Consumers
Union, which publishes Consumer Reports. “They need more money and resources
to do more checks.”
Most recalls are done voluntarily, as was the case with
Thomas & Friends, after companies discover problems or receive
complaints.
Among the toy recalls, the problem is most acute with low-price,
no-brand-name toys that are often sold at dollar stores and other deep
discounters, which are manufactured and sent to the United States often without
the involvement of major American toy importers. Last year, China also was the
source of 81 percent of the counterfeit goods seized by Customs officials at
ports of entry in the United States — products that typically are not made
according to the standards on the labels they are copying.
I’m sure you don’t need me to tell you that this is unacceptable! In the meantime there is something you can do to protect you and your family from dangerous toys made in China, here is a link to the
Consumer Product Safety Commission’s e-mail notification of recalled products. The CPSC will send you notification when they are made aware of unsafe products, hopefully that will be in a timely manner instead of 2 years after purchasing the product. The 2nd NY Times article can be found
here (password required).